Full Version : WOW NOW I'VE SEEN EVERYTHING !
ihwcforums >>IHWC General >>WOW NOW I'VE SEEN EVERYTHING !


<< Prev | Next >>

Aurelia- 05-12-2008
QUOTE (Sch 12 rus 0 @ May 12, 2008 02:12 pm)
QUOTE
Thanks for clearing that up. So no bias at all, the guy was merely incompetent.


Ridiculous ..that was NOT DUE TO INCOMPETENCE...No one who is not either a/ BLIND or b/ BLATANTLY CHEATING ...could have looked at that replay and called it a goal...


Here is what was said by the SWEDISH judge who WAS NOT an official goal judge (but one was not present at the game):

It looked like a 100 % clear goal, so he only looked at the tape once. The puck was in! But as soon as he had said yes it's a goal, he realised what was wrong: how the puck got there. He yelled at the referees, but it was too late, as he was pointing to the centre already.

And this cost him his job, as he has been fired.

Sch 12 rus 0- 05-12-2008
QUOTE
The USA ought to file an official pro-*test*-('") to replay the game or run back the score to 2-2 and start an overtime session.


Filing an official pro-*test*-('") is fine...but that would be purely perfunctory...there is NO way to replay that game at this point in the tourney...It wouldn't be fair to the FINNS, Hell it wouldn't even be fair to the Yanks..they had no chance to finish first in the Pool Anyway...So other than making a point to the IIHF official-DUMB, which I could totally see...and maybe seeking some explanation/ assurances that they will try to improve the ‘ quality/ fairness' of Vid Judges in the future...there's nothing else to be gained...

This could actually help Yanks in a backhanded kinda way...to develop an us against the world etc mindset...Should they meet Suomi again in the QF's ( which I'm betting on ) they'l be a HIGHLY MOTIVATED BUNCH !...

mapleleaf4ever- 05-12-2008
QUOTE (Aurelia @ May 12, 2008 02:42 pm)
QUOTE (Sch 12 rus 0 @ May 12, 2008 02:12 pm)
QUOTE
Thanks for clearing that up. So no bias at all, the guy was merely incompetent.


Ridiculous ..that was NOT DUE TO INCOMPETENCE...No one who is not either a/ BLIND or b/ BLATANTLY CHEATING ...could have looked at that replay and called it a goal...


Here is what the SWEDISH judge who WAS NOT an official goal judge (but one was not present at the game) made the call said:

It looked like a 100 % clear goal, so he only looked at the tape once. The puck was in! But as soon as he had said yes it's a goal, he realised what was wrong: how the puck got there. He yelled at the referees, but it was too late, as he was pointing to the centre already.

And this cost him his job, as he has been fired.

Well an honest mistake.

this story is done. ihwcforums/rip.gif


Sch 12 rus 0- 05-12-2008
QUOTE
Here is what the SWEDISH judge who made the call said:

It looked like a 100 % clear goal, so he only looked at the tape once. The puck was in!


Sorry BUT that's BULLSHYTE...Even if u watched the replay ONLY once...from the BEGINNING...U'd see right away that that puck was SAILING WAY WIDE...

Hell the puck was nowhere near the goal mouth at any point...and that's clear from its Trajectory VERY EARLY ON...

AGAIN...only a BLIND MAN/ or a BLATANT CHEATER imo could honestly claim to have seen otherwise

In plain language...ONLY a Gullible individual would believe this guys story...Hells Bells...What did u expect him to say ‘ YEAH I CHEATED'

Christ...Not even a Swede, outside of that dullard BAG their Head coach ( see his comments in OG 06 prior to the SVK game ) would be that friggen STUPID ! smile.gif

***

This Ex-Video Judge deserves a thorough grilling/questioning by both USAhockey & IIHF officials....Again I'd wanna know precisely what replay he saw...For example, did they send him replays from SEVERAL DIFFERENT ANGLES ?....If so, how can he claim to have watched only one? and which one does he ' claim' to have watched ? Bet he'd start stuttering/ stammering right away when asked that question... Also...I'd wanna know if this guy has a checkered past...Has he ever been involved in other controversies/ been accused of cheating before ???

INQUIRING MINDS WANNA KNOW...& THAT'S ONLY FAIR IN MY BOOKS...BUT NO...

Don't give me this ‘ sorry, I only watched it once...+ with one eye closed ...yadda yadda ...BULLSHYTE

Sorry but I dont think he should be allowed to get off the hook that easy...I'd say he has a bit more to answer to...

AirdefMike- 05-12-2008
Lol!

Stop schooley...you're making an ass of yourself. The game is over...the story's been done as was said.

You're just trying to make this look bigger than it really was.

Sch 12 rus 0- 05-12-2008
QUOTE
Lol!

Stop schooley...you're making an ASS of yourself


Hmmm...Here's another NewsFlash...I have a right to express my opinion here ...same as u...without being insulted by you...did I start with the personal insults ? NO..that was U kiddo...

ERGO...in plain language...GO ###### URSELF FINN ( NB* no smiley )

The ops I'm expressing here...I fully believe...

Less u forget 2 WhipperSnapper...I'm older than u...ERGO...I've seen a helluva lot more of this IIHF Biased judgements than u have...

Without doubt , in my mind at least...Yank officials have every right to probe further/ talk to this guy directly, & in the presence of IIHF official-dumb...

Their guys have worked hard in this tourney...only to be ROBBED Yesterday ....As redress...I think that's the least the IIHF etc could do...if so, requested... anything less is just HERESAY...

U think if this kinda thing happened in the NHL playoffs...this video judge wouldn't be grilled further ? OF COURSE HE BLOODY WOULD !

CHEERS

Aurora Borealis- 05-12-2008
QUOTE (Sch 12 rus 0 @ May 12, 2008 02:12 pm)
QUOTE
Thanks for clearing that up. So no bias at all, the guy was merely incompetent.


Ridiculous ..that was NOT DUE TO INCOMPETENCE...No one who is not either a/ BLIND or b/ BLATANTLY CHEATING ...could have looked at that replay and called it a goal...

The only incompetence was on the part of those other IIHF officials who chose that BIASED/ UNCONSCIONABLE Swede vid judge in the first place...

If I was the Americans...I'd want to see what replays that judge was given...and I'd want to watch them in the presence of IIHF head of officiating...

I'd alwo want to talk to the Vid judge himself...Then I'd want an explanation for what transpired...and again crying ' simple incompetence' does NOT CUT IT...

I ment it wasn't biased cause I figured a Swede wouldn't help the Finns (yes, I love my stereotypes).

Since I doubt he was blind and he couldn't have been that dumb and cheated so obvious, I think it is due to incompetence, as he was unable to do his job.

The game can't be replayed (probably not enough time) and the guy's fired. No point in arguing about this anymore, since we all know this tourney has shit referees.

Sch 12 rus 0- 05-12-2008
QUOTE
If TC needs this kind of motivating then? LOL to that. Maybe you're in love with the US of A deep down since as a matter of fact you turned this into a Finn bashing by accusing of us (of the IIHF) cheating.


I never accused any member of Team Suomi of anything untoward...In fact I REPEATEDLY said much the opposite...

Newsflash the Finnish Hockey federation is NOT the IIHF...nor is HockeyCanada, nor USAHOCKEY...so quit talking NONSENSE...

I said the IIHF has made MANY biased judgements in the past...COMPLETELY TRUE...& I said that this video review judge was either BLIND or BLATANTLY CHEATING...I still believe that , that's why ( if I was Team USA etc) I'd want to question him further

As for cheering for Yanks vs. Euros...YUP ...I usually Do...BUT that's MY PEROGATIVE GOT IT...

QUOTE
Now...who has quite vocal about Europeans crying foul and calling conspiracies?

Wasn't me.


Actually I said that about SOME ( read MANY ) Russians...never said that about FINNS....

As for the rest, you're point is STILL COMPLETELY BOGUS...The Russians ( such as Fetisov in 0G 02 ) made wild conspiracy claims with NO FRIGGEN EVIDENCE...

I SAW THE FRIGGEN VIDEO EVIDENCE REPEATEDLY...Ergo...My comments are NOT BASELESS...so kindly STFU !

CHEERS

Finnjävel- 05-12-2008
Personally i think that first goal just compensates all those unfair penalties against Finland. If USA was to win that match, it would have done so during the huge number of unfair PP they got.. To be honest, Team US looked like Italy in football: rediculous acting to get referees symphaties(especially that Koivu´s penalty). And it worked for 2 periods. In the third US showed its real face(?), spearing and checking to the head after whistle. Those guys should be banned from this tournament for good before they end someones career or kill someone. But I agree with Tortorella: OJ should have longer penalty, purely because it helps TF,
If we are to loose tonights game against Canada(its not a shame) and to face USA once more, just bring them on! This time there would be no controversy!
This topic should get a burial soon. Its just getting annoying

Aurelia- 05-12-2008
QUOTE (Mr Spock @ May 12, 2008 02:21 pm)
QUOTE (Aurelia @ May 11, 2008 11:27 pm)
Everything about the judging in this game was so off. And we agree, the goal was a bit ridiculous. It shouldn't happen. But we'll take it, as do everyone that get benefited by someone else's mistake. Frankly, for once it wasn't Sweden who got a goal like that smile.gif.

Now what was that?????????????????????

By that I mean that we Finns feel (as quite a few nations do about their own team) that someone else always has Lady Luck on their side. And of course we joke about it always being Sweden (and sometimes it really is). I didn't mean Sweden has literally scored a goal like that.

AirdefMike- 05-12-2008
to schooley:

Yeah, I'm younger than you...I'm only followed int. hockey since late 1980. So, what do I know?

If you make a claim that cheating has been done in favor of Finns....then you're accusing that Finns had something to do with it.

Don't be so coy about it. You're much too old for that wink.gif

Since you're willing to forget the smileys and drop the gloves....I'm game but I'm afraid you have to prove the actual cheating.

Aurelia- 05-12-2008
^ Especially since the guy who made the call has clearly stated that he is not a video judge, and that he made an honest mistake, and even tried to make it right but it was just a second too late.

Personally, I believe him. He was not a professional, and was asked if it was a goal. Well, hell yeah, the puck is in! And then you realise that wasn't what they were after... But how the puck got there.

SCH does keep saying that he doesn't blame Finns... But who else would come up with a conspiracy to help Finns?? And why? I don't get it.

dryden- 05-12-2008
QUOTE (Aurelia @ May 12, 2008 10:34 am)
Well, dryden, we can agree to disagree. Maybe you choose to misunderstand some of my points, yes, of course Canada plays as a team as well, of course Jokinen and Selänne can be called scorers, of course Shedden is allowed to try out stuff.

I'm just looking at these things from a different point of view, and perhaps with a different understanding than you since I am a Finn, and much of my analysis is ALWAYS coloured with humor and should not be taken as a challenge to argue smile.gif.

I can acknowledge that you have good points too, perhaps you can admit that Shedden - though he comes from God's Chosen Country - might be wrong sometimes.

In the end, however, I will stand by my Lions till the bitter/sweet/bittersweet end.

I don't think i misundertood your points and i didn't take it as an excuse to argue..............................just didn't agree and when i don't i'll make counterpoints which is what this place is all about of course.


I definately agree with your point about Gods country though.......................no need for counterpoint there!!!


All i'm saying is so far you guys don't have a loss on your record.

But i'll be more then happy to end that unblemished record today and give you guys all the excuses in the world to rip Shedden to peices biggrin.gif


make sure not to go easy on the guy!!!

i know you won't biggrin.gif

Aurelia- 05-12-2008
We don't have a loss... Just barely, after almost sinking against Norway and Latvia. The Slovakia game was horrible too! So we're not happy. We have no proof yet that he can take us all the way.

And no, I won't spare my words if he screws this up for us biggrin.gif.

dryden- 05-12-2008
QUOTE (bomcan @ May 12, 2008 11:06 am)
OK, Finland won fairly IMO irrespective of the disputed goal but this just shows that there is a huuuge bias against the Americans in particular. I am 100% sure the video ref in question was a Canadian and that he miscalled it on purpose. I also heard from one of our commentators this -- the Americans prepare printed materials before each game containing stats and other information and before one game at least the Can person responsible for the distribution of said materials just dumped them in a rubbish bin. Who needs that? I know, i know there's alot of passion but don't push it beyond what's reasonable, ok?

So you're lumberjack then eh?

you're posts leave you as incognito as a robber trying to get into your house with tin cans tied to his feet.

Free Forum Hosting by Forumer.comTM!